The silence from the bat of Shohei Ohtani is now echoing through the entire Los Angeles Dodgers clubhouse, and for the first time this season, the superstar has broken his own sacred pregame routine in a desperate search for answers that simply did not come. On Wednesday afternoon at Dodger Stadium, Ohtani took live batting practice before a game for the first time since his historic postseason run last October, a move that immediately sent shockwaves through the baseball world and signaled that the two-time MVP knows something is fundamentally wrong with his swing. The batting practice session was electric, with Cleveland Guardians players actually stopping their own warmups to watch Ohtani launch baseballs into the outfield seats, but the results when it mattered most were devastating. Ohtani went 0 for 4 with a strikeout and a rally-killing double play groundout, leaving the Dodgers to absorb a 3-1 loss to the Guardians and raising serious questions about whether this offense is experiencing early season noise or something far more troubling.

The Dodgers have now played six games, and their superstar designated hitter is hitting under .200 with an alarming lack of production that has infected the entire heart of the order. This is not just about Ohtani, though his struggles are the most visible and the most concerning given his history as a creature of habit who never deviates from his preparation. The fact that he felt compelled to take batting practice on a day when manager Dave Roberts had given the team the option to skip it tells you everything you need to know about where his head is at right now. Ohtani is the ultimate professional, the kind of player who follows the same routine every single day with religious precision, and he just blew up that routine because he knows something is off. The problem is that the batting practice worked beautifully, but the game did not, and that disconnect is exactly what has the baseball world buzzing with a mixture of panic and patience.

Let us be clear about what happened in that game because the details matter. Ohtani walked in the first inning, showing patience at the plate, but then came the at-bats that have defined his first week of the season. In the third inning, with a runner on first base, he struck out swinging at pitches that were not competitive. In the sixth inning, with runners on first and second and the Dodgers trailing 2-0, Ohtani grounded into a double play that essentially ended any chance of a rally. The Guardians pitcher had just walked the number nine hitter, a clear sign of vulnerability, and here comes Ohtani with a chance to change the game, and he swung at the first pitch he saw and rolled it over to second base. That at-bat was not just unproductive, it was damaging, and it came at a moment when the Dodgers desperately needed their best hitter to deliver. Then in the eighth inning, with another opportunity to do damage, Ohtani struck out on three pitches, two of which were out of the zone, and the game was effectively over.
The numbers through six games are ugly, but they are also meaningless in the grand scheme of a 162-game season. Ohtani is tied for the major league lead in walks, which shows he is still seeing the ball and still has discipline, but his batting average is below the Mendoza line and his slugging percentage is nowhere near what we expect from a player who hit 54 home runs last season. The panic meter is low for anyone who understands baseball, but the concern meter is slightly elevated because of the approach, not the results. Ohtani is swinging at bad pitches early in counts, he is expanding the strike zone, and he is not making pitchers pay for their mistakes. When you are the best hitter on the planet, pitchers are going to be careful with you, and when you help them by swinging at their pitches instead of waiting for yours, you are playing right into their hands. That is what is happening right now, and that is what has the Dodgers’ coaching staff watching closely.

But here is the thing about baseball that makes it the most maddening sport in the world, one game can change everything. Ohtani went through a similar stretch last season before the NLCS, and then he hit three home runs in a single game and everyone forgot about the struggles. The Dodgers are 4-2 despite their offense being virtually silent for long stretches, and that is the sign of a championship caliber team that knows how to win ugly. Freddie Freeman finally broke through with a solo home run in the ninth inning of Wednesday’s loss, and that could be the spark that ignites this entire lineup. The Dodgers have not scored in the first two innings of any game this season, and they rank near the bottom of baseball in first inning run production, but they are still winning games because their pitching has been outstanding. Yoshinobu Yamamoto gave up just two runs over six innings on Wednesday, and that should have been enough to win, but the offense let him down.
The concern extends beyond Ohtani because the entire top of the lineup is cold. Mookie Betts is struggling, Kyle Tucker has been inconsistent, Will Smith is just starting to find his swing, and Max Muncy has not looked like himself. Only Andy Pages, who went 3 for 3 on Wednesday, seems to be hitting the ball with any consistency. The Dodgers have one of the most talented lineups in baseball history on paper, but paper does not win games, and right now that lineup is not producing. The good news is that the Dodgers are leaving Los Angeles for a road trip that will take them to Washington and Toronto, and sometimes a change of scenery is exactly what a struggling team needs. The bad news is that the Nationals have some young arms that could give this lineup fits if they continue to press.
The Ohtani situation is the story that will dominate headlines because he is the biggest star in the sport, and when he struggles, everyone notices. He is not just any player, he is the player who changed the way baseball is played, the player who signed the largest contract in professional sports history, the player who is supposed to carry this team to another championship. When he takes batting practice for the first time in months, it is news. When he goes 0 for 4 with a double play and a strikeout after that batting practice, it is a crisis. But let us be honest about what we are seeing, this is a slow start, nothing more. Ohtani has been through slumps before, and he has always come out of them. The question is whether this slump will last another week or another month, and nobody knows the answer to that question.
The Dodgers made a roster move on Wednesday that flew under the radar but could have significant implications for the pitching staff. They placed Gavin Stone on the 60-day injured list, a move that opens up a spot on the 40-man roster but also raises questions about Stone’s recovery from the shoulder surgery that cost him the entire 2025 season. Stone was one of the Dodgers’ most reliable starters two years ago, and his absence has created a void in the rotation that the team is still trying to fill. The 60-day IL designation means Stone will not be available until at least June, and given the typical ramp up period for a pitcher returning from injury, it could be July or August before he is ready to contribute at the major league level. The Dodgers also acquired left-handed pitcher Jake Eder from the Nationals and claimed right-hander Grant Holman off waivers from the Diamondbacks, depth moves that could pay dividends later in the season.
The Gavin Stone situation is worth watching because it speaks to the Dodgers’ overall pitching depth, which is both a strength and a vulnerability. The team has Yamamoto, Tyler Glasnow, and a collection of young arms that have shown promise, but they are one injury away from being in trouble. Stone was supposed to be part of the solution, and now he is not going to be available for at least two months. The Dodgers are masters of finding hidden gems and developing them into contributors, but even they cannot replace a pitcher of Stone’s caliber overnight. The moves they made on Wednesday are insurance policies, nothing more, but they are the kind of moves that championship teams make to ensure they have options when things go wrong.
The fan reaction to this slow start has been predictably divided, with some calling for patience and others expressing genuine concern. The Dodgers have the highest payroll in baseball, they have the most star power, and they are expected to win the World Series every year. When they lose two out of three games at home to the Guardians, a team that is not expected to contend, the alarm bells start ringing. But here is the reality, the Dodgers are 4-2, they have played six games, and they have not hit the ball well at all. If they were 2-4, there would be reason to panic, but they are not. They are winning games despite their struggles, and that is the mark of a great team. The offense will come around, it always does, and when it does, the Dodgers will be even more dangerous than they already are.
The road trip that begins on Friday against the Nationals could be exactly what this team needs to break out of its funk. The Nationals are not a good team, and their pitching staff is young and inconsistent. If the Dodgers can get to them early and build some confidence, they could carry that momentum into Toronto and continue to build. The key is for Ohtani to have one good game, one game where he hits a home run or drives in a few runs, and suddenly everything will feel different. Baseball is a game of confidence, and right now, the Dodgers’ best hitter is lacking confidence. That will change, it always does, but the question is when.
The Dodgers’ offense is not broken, it is just cold. There is a difference between being broken and being cold, and this team is cold. The talent is there, the track record is there, and the results will come. The question is whether the Dodgers can continue to win games while they wait for their bats to heat up. So far, they have done exactly that, and that is a good sign. The pitching has been good enough to keep them in games, and the bullpen has been solid. If the offense can start producing, this team will be unstoppable. If it does not, they will still win games because they have the best pitching in the National League. The Dodgers are fine, but they are not great right now, and that is okay. It is April, and there is a long way to go.