FORT RILEY, Kansas — Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer has delivered a harrowing firsthand account of the United States Army’s spring campaign against the Plains tribes, revealing a scene of such brutality that he declared the details “too sickening for these pages.”
In a narrative that lays bare the savage realities of the 1867 Hancock Expedition, Custer describes the discovery of a young mixed-race girl, roughly ten years old, deliberately abandoned by the fleeing Sioux and Cheyenne. The child was found cowering in a darkened lodge, wrapped in a buffalo robe, after the entire village had vanished into the night to escape the approaching column of 1,400 soldiers.
The abandonment itself was shocking, but Custer’s account takes a darker turn. He alleges that before the tribes retreated, a group of young warriors returned to the deserted lodge and inflicted upon the helpless girl outrages so vile that he refused to commit the specifics to print. “They committed upon this helpless girl outrages, the details of which cannot be inscribed in these pages,” Custer wrote in his memoir, “My Life on the Plains.”
The discovery was made in the dead of night after Custer, acting on orders from General Winfield Scott Hancock, executed a silent, encircling maneuver around the village located on Pawnee Fork, near Fort Larned. The operation was fraught with tension, as Custer and his men crept forward, uncertain if they were surrounding a sleeping populace or walking into an ambush.
The tension broke when the scouts realized the village was a ghost town. The fires were still burning, and the lodges were fully furnished, indicating a panicked, last-minute flight. It was during the systematic search of the empty tipis that Custer and the regiment’s physician, Dr.
Coates, stumbled upon the girl. The doctor, who had been exploring the culinary habits of the tribe, had moments earlier partaken of a stew he found simmering over a fire, only to be informed by the half-breed interpreter, Gorie, that he had just eaten dog meat.
The girl, terrified and alone, was not the only soul left behind. The search also uncovered a decrepit Sioux man, too aged and infirm to keep pace with the retreating band. Both were taken into the Army’s care, with Custer noting that the girl was placed in the hands of “kind and tender hearts” at the fort.
Custer’s narrative, published in 1874, serves as a stark justification for the military’s presence on the plains. He frames the expedition not as an act of aggression, but as a necessary show of force to curb the “numerous thefts and murders” committed by the Cheyenne and Sioux against frontier settlers. He points to the attacks on stage stations, the burning of property, and the killing of citizens, including women like Mrs.
Marlin and Mrs. Ward, who were abducted and never heard from again.
The campaign, led personally by General Hancock, was massive in scope, comprising eight companies of cavalry, seven of infantry, and a battery of light artillery. Its stated purpose, according to letters quoted by Custer, was to “convince the Indians… that we are able to punish any of them who may molest travellers across the plains or commit other acts of hostility against the whites.”
However, the general’s overtures for peace were met with suspicion and delay. The tribes, still haunted by the memory of the Chivington Massacre at Sand Creek, fled at the sight of the soldiers, fearing another slaughter. Custer describes a tense standoff where hundreds of warriors formed a glittering battle line across the army’s path, only to claim they desired peace when confronted by General Hancock.
The climax came on the night of April 14th. After the chiefs failed to appear for a promised council, Hancock ordered Custer to surround the village. The cavalry moved with muffled silence, their sabers fixed to prevent clanging, using the glow of the village fires as their guide.
When the moon broke through the clouds, it revealed the entire regiment forming a perfect circle around the encampment, a sight Custer called “beautiful as it was interesting.”
Yet, the prize was empty. The birds had flown. The only remnants of the village’s inhabitants were the abandoned belongings, the simmering pots, and the two forsaken souls.
Custer noted that the Indians had even set fire to the prairie grass in a desperate attempt to hinder the army’s advance, a tactic that failed to stop the determined column.
The fate of the young girl remains a haunting footnote in this chapter of frontier history. Custer’s account, while graphic in its description of the campaign’s maneuvers, remains frustratingly vague on the specifics of the girl’s ordeal, citing the sheer horror of the acts as his reason for omission. He does, however, offer a possible explanation for her cruel treatment: her mixed-race heritage, suggesting she may have been a captive from another tribe, such as the Pawnee, making her an outcast even among her captors.
This incident, as recounted by Custer, underscores the brutal cycle of violence that defined the American frontier. The Army’s campaign, intended to punish past sins and deter future ones, resulted in the displacement of a village and the abandonment of its most vulnerable members. The general’s own words paint a picture of a conflict where neither side held a monopoly on cruelty, yet the image of a ten-year-old girl, left to the mercy of the night and the worst instincts of her own people, serves as a grim testament to the human cost of westward expansion.
Custer’s memoir, written two years before his death at the Little Bighorn, stands as a primary source document of a bygone era, offering a stark, unvarnished look at the attitudes and events that shaped the nation. His account of the girl’s rescue is a brief, tragic interlude in a larger story of military strategy and cultural clash, but it is one that resonates with a profound and unsettling power. The general’s decision to shield the public from the full details of the crime speaks volumes about the depths of depravity he witnessed on the plains, a darkness that even a hardened cavalryman found difficult to articulate.
The expedition would continue its march, but the memory of that empty village and the girl left behind would linger. For Custer, it was evidence of the character of the enemy he faced. For the reader, it is a window into a world of unrelenting hardship, where the rules of civilization were suspended, and survival often came at the cost of innocence.
The girl, now under the protection of the U. S. military, was a symbol of the chaos the army was sent to tame, a living casualty of a war with no clean hands.