The New York Yankees are exploring a surprising strategy for filling their third base vacancy as they head into the 2025 season. Recent reports indicate that instead of pursuing big-name acquisitions like Alex Bregman or Nolan Arenado, the Yankees are leaning towards their internal options. This decision has left fans questioning whether it is the right approach for a team that aims to reclaim championship glory.
Currently, the Yankees have eight of their nine starting lineup spots secured, with the third base position remaining a significant uncertainty. According to ESPN’s Jorge Castillo, the front office is monitoring the market, but the solution may already lie within the clubhouse. The leading candidates for the role include DJ LeMahieu, Oswaldo Cabrera, and Oswald Peraza.
LeMahieu, while a familiar face, is showing signs of decline at 36 years old, having posted a disappointing .204 batting average last season. His veteran experience is valuable, but relying on him as a full-time solution poses a considerable risk. Cabrera brings versatility, having played multiple positions, yet his offensive production has also been below average, with a .661 OPS in 2024.
Peraza presents the most intriguing option. He has demonstrated potential in the minor leagues and boasts solid defensive skills, but he remains unproven at the major league level. This season could be critical for him to establish himself as a reliable contributor.
Notably, hopes for a blockbuster signing are dwindling. The Yankees’ reluctance to engage in high-profile deals raises concerns about their commitment to winning. General Manager Brian Cashman and owner Hal Steinbrenner have emphasized their desire to capture another World Series title, yet their current strategy may not suffice against teams like the Dodgers and Braves.
With a disappointing season behind them, the Yankees must weigh the risks of relying on unproven talent versus making impactful acquisitions. As the season unfolds, the front office may need to reconsider their approach if internal candidates fail to meet expectations. For Yankees fans, the question remains: is trusting Peraza, Cabrera, and LeMahieu the best path forward, or should the team pursue a big-name player to bolster their lineup?
