🏆 The Real NFC North Running Back Rankings (Stats Don’t Lie) Where Does Josh Jacobs Rank? #TM

🚨 PACKERS FANS WON’T LIKE THIS! PFF’S NFC NORTH RUNNING BACK RANKINGS ARE IGNITING A MASSIVE CONTROVERSY — AND JOSH JACOBS IS RIGHT AT THE CENTER OF IT 🚨

🏆 The Real NFC North Running Back Rankings (Stats Don't Lie) Where Does  Josh Jacobs Rank?

Just when Packers fans thought Josh Jacobs had finally silenced every doubter after another productive season, a brand-new ranking has reignited one of the biggest debates in the NFC North. And honestly, it’s already dividing fans across the league. According to Pro Football Focus, Jacobs remains one of the conference’s elite running backs, earning an impressive 85.8 overall grade. Sounds great, right? Well, not everyone agrees. In fact, some analysts believe PFF may have been far too generous, arguing that Jacobs’ final grade doesn’t tell the full story of what actually happened on the field. The criticism has quickly exploded into one simple question: Is Josh Jacobs really the best running back in the NFC North, or has Green Bay’s star been getting more credit than he deserves?

The numbers certainly make the debate interesting. PFF ranked Jacobs just ahead of Detroit superstar Jahmyr Gibbs, who finished with an 85.6 grade after another electrifying season. Chicago’s D’Andre Swift wasn’t far behind at 83.0, while Minnesota’s Jordan Mason checked in at 74.4. On paper, that suggests Jacobs narrowly sits atop one of the league’s most competitive divisions. But here’s where everything gets complicated. Several analysts reviewing the rankings believe the grades fail to capture what actually showed up on film. While Jacobs piled up production and once again proved capable of carrying a heavy workload, critics argue he also left far too many yards on the field. Missed cutback lanes. Runs that could have gone for explosive gains. Opportunities that simply weren’t maximized. According to those analysts, Jacobs’ physical running style remains incredibly valuable, but his overall efficiency wasn’t nearly as dominant as the final grade might suggest.

Josh Jacobs relishes his role in NFL's running back revival

And honestly…

That’s where Packers fans are starting to push back.

Because context matters.

Jacobs wasn’t running behind a dominant offensive line.

Far from it.

Green Bay’s run blocking struggled for long stretches of the season, forcing Jacobs to fight through contact almost immediately after taking the handoff. Add in the fact that he reportedly battled injuries for nearly half the season, and suddenly his production becomes much more impressive. Instead of criticizing the missed opportunities, many Packers fans see a running back who consistently created positive plays despite difficult circumstances. They point to his toughness, durability, and ability to grind out difficult yards when defenses knew exactly what was coming. Those qualities don’t always appear on stat sheets, but they win football games.

Still, the Jahmyr Gibbs comparison refuses to go away.

And it’s easy to understand why.

Josh Jacobs re-emerging as one of the NFL's elite RBs again…

Gibbs brings a completely different style to the position. His explosive speed allows him to turn ordinary plays into highlight-reel touchdowns almost instantly. According to advanced Next Gen Stats, Gibbs ranked among the league leaders in explosive runs that exceeded expected rushing yardage, constantly creating chunk plays that changed games in a matter of seconds. That’s an area where Jacobs simply doesn’t match him. The Packers’ running back has never relied on pure speed. His game is built around power, balance, vision, and wearing down defenses over four quarters instead of outrunning everyone to the end zone.

That’s exactly why comparing the two has become so difficult.

They’re elite…

But in completely different ways.

Need someone to break a 70-yard touchdown on any snap?

You’ll probably take Gibbs.

Need someone to hammer into stacked defensive fronts, pick up tough first downs, dominate short-yardage situations, and control the clock late in games?

Josh Jacobs suddenly becomes the obvious choice.

Even more fascinating, both players finished the season with 13 rushing touchdowns despite their completely different playing styles. That alone shows just how valuable each has become to his respective offense. One wins with explosiveness. The other wins with relentless physicality.

Meanwhile, another Packers running back is quietly beginning to generate excitement behind the scenes.

Chris Brooks.

Does Packers' Josh Jacobs have a fumbling issue? It might be the 'cheetah  effect' - The Athletic

While he played only a limited number of offensive snaps, several analysts believe Brooks may have been one of Green Bay’s most underrated offensive contributors. Every time he touched the football, he seemed to maximize the opportunity. No costly mistakes. No obvious missed assignments. Reliable in pass protection. Effective as a runner. Dependable whenever his number was called. Some observers have even suggested Brooks deserves a significantly larger role this season, especially if the Packers want to keep Jacobs fresh for another postseason run.

When you step back and look at the bigger picture, this debate isn’t really about whether Josh Jacobs is a good running back.

Everyone agrees he is.

The real question is much bigger.

Is he truly the best running back in the NFC North?

Or has Jahmyr Gibbs already taken that crown?

Packers fans will point to toughness.

Lions fans will point to explosiveness.

The numbers support both arguments.

The film tells two different stories.

And as long as Green Bay and Detroit continue battling for NFC North supremacy, this debate isn’t going anywhere.

Because sometimes the fiercest rivalries aren’t decided by quarterbacks.

Sometimes they’re decided by the men carrying the football.

And right now, Josh Jacobs and Jahmyr Gibbs are giving NFL fans one of the most heated running back debates in football.