As the MLB offseason progresses, the New York Yankees are reportedly eyeing a significant move to bolster their lineup. The focus is on infielder Luis Rengifo of the Los Angeles Angels, a player who could address some pressing issues within the Yankees’ roster ahead of the 2025 season.

The Yankees’ current offensive performance has raised concerns, particularly outside of star players Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. With a league ranking of 21st in Weighted Runs Created Plus (WRC+) at 92, the team is in dire need of enhancement, especially at second and third base, where offensive production has fallen short. Rengifo, who has demonstrated versatility as a switch-hitter capable of playing both positions, may be the solution.

Before suffering a right wrist injury, Rengifo posted an impressive WRC+ of 127 and a batting average of .315, showcasing his potential to contribute significantly to the Yankees’ offense. At 27 years old, he has shown marked improvement in his batting discipline, evidenced by a reduced strikeout rate of 13.4% over the past two seasons. Additionally, his speed on the bases has been notable, with 22 stolen bases in 28 attempts this season.

However, Rengifo’s defensive capabilities have raised eyebrows. His career statistics reflect challenges, including a -7 runs above average rating and a history of costly errors, which could jeopardize the Yankees’ established infield defense, regarded as one of the best in the league.

The potential acquisition of Rengifo comes with its share of risks, particularly regarding the possibility of regression in his batting numbers and concerns about his recovery from injury. Yankees fans now face a pivotal question: should the team take a gamble on a player with upside to enhance their offense, or prioritize the defensive consistency already present in the lineup? As discussions continue, fans are encouraged to weigh in on this crucial decision.