In a shocking case that has captivated the nation, Steven Allwine was convicted of murdering his wife, Amy Allwine, after a chilling plot involving the dark web unfolded. The case, which began with an FBI investigation into a murder-for-hire scheme targeting Amy, culminated in a courtroom drama revealing betrayal and deceit.
The Allwines, a seemingly perfect couple from Minnesota, lived a life dedicated to faith and family. However, in May 2016, FBI agents knocked on their door, revealing that Amy was the intended target of a hitman linked to a dark web site called Basa Mafia. This site, known for facilitating murders for hire, turned out to be a scam, but the threat was very real.
As the investigation progressed, it became clear that Steven was not just a victim but a key player in the dark web dealings. Under the alias “Dog Day God,” he attempted to hire a hitman to kill his wife, frustrated when the scheme fell through. The FBI uncovered a trail of digital evidence linking Steven to the site and the murder plot.
On November 13, 2016, tragedy struck when Amy was found dead in their home, a gunshot wound to her head. Initial reports suggested suicide, but the evidence told a different story. The trajectory of the bullet and the absence of gunshot residue on Amy’s hands raised immediate suspicions.
Detectives quickly turned their focus to Steven, whose inconsistent statements and emotional detachment during the 911 call raised red flags. Further investigation revealed that he had been having multiple affairs and had purchased drugs online, including Scopolamine, which was found in Amy’s system at lethal levels.
The evidence mounted against Steven: he had meticulously plotted his wife’s murder, attempting to cover his tracks with digital anonymity. The investigation revealed that he had searched for Amy’s personal information and sent her threatening emails under a false identity, deepening the betrayal.
In January 2017, Steven was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. The prosecution presented a compelling case, highlighting his motive driven by financial gain from Amy’s life insurance policy and his desire to escape their marriage without facing the consequences.
After a lengthy trial, a jury found Steven guilty, sentencing him to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The judge condemned him as a “cold hypocrite,” underscoring the depth of his betrayal.
Five years later, the case remains a haunting reminder of the darkness that can lurk beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary lives. Amy Allwine’s tragic death serves as a testament to the dangers of betrayal, leaving a family shattered and a community in mourning.
